HomeConstitutional LawLegal HistoryLegal EthicsEvidenceProfessional ResponsibilityContact MeSearch

   

Supreme Court Justices

Peter Daniel (1784 - 1860)

Peter Daniel was born in April 1784 in Virginia. Like a number of well born Virginians, he attended the College of New Jersey (now Princeton). Daniel returned to Richmond to read law under Edmund Randolph, a well-known and regarded Virginia lawyer who was the first Attorney General of the United States, appointed by George Washington. In 1808, Daniel married Randolph's daughter Lucy. Daniel's career was more as a political advisor than as a lawyer. For over two decades (1812-35), Daniel served on the Privy Council in Virginia, which acted as the governor's advisory council. He also served as lieutenant governor in Virginia. In 1836, Andrew Jackson appointed Daniel to the federal district court after Philip Barbour was appointed to the Supreme Court. Five years later, Daniel again followed in Barbour's footsteps. President Martin Van Buren nominated Daniel to the Court after Barbour's death in early 1841. Daniel distrusted corporations, northerners and anyone agitating for an end to slavery. In the Court's tumultuous 1842 Term, he wrote a separate opinion in Prigg v. Pennsylvania, which held that the Fugitive Slave Act of 1793 was supreme over state law, and joined in the Court's opinion in Swift v. Tyson. Daniel's inflammatory concurring opinion in Dred Scott v. Sandford, aided in the worsening of relations between North and South in the late 1850s. Daniels first raised the stakes in Dred Scott, claiming that the case was more important than any other the Court had decided. He then called the United States an "American Confederacy,"  a phrasing he used in Prigg, and declared that "that the African negro race never have been acknowledged as belonging to the family of nations." The remainder of Daniel's concurrence was an effort to find authorities in international law and in western (European) legal history to support the Court's conclusion the Dred Scott was not a citizen, that the Missouri Compromise was unconstitutional, and that the "once free, always free" doctrine was not a doctrine in law.

Daniel married his second wife in 1853. He died in Richmond in May 1860.